1998 Holden Barina 1.4 City 1.4

Summary:

This car is great as a second car, for commuting economically and with great reliability

Faults:

Only a few minor electrical items such as rear bulbs and switchgear lighting.

Regular servicing items such as brake pads, tyres, battery and wiper blades have been replaced, however no major items have given any trouble at all, despite a high mileage.

The rear wheel bearings are beginning to get noisy and will need replacing within the next 50,000km.

General Comments:

This car has been completely reliable and still travels approx 800 - 1000km per week.

Performance is adequate for my type of driving, however I have found that it gets a lot worse in the hot weather. This is nothing to do with the air conditioner, as this is on nearly all the time. It just seems much more sluggish when the temp gets above about 28 degrees C.

Paintwork on my silver car is looking pretty shabby, with quite a bit of fading and scuff marks.

Economical to run.

Would you buy another car from this manufacturer? Yes

Review Date: 7th March, 2004

1998 Holden Barina City 1.4

Summary:

The cutest, cheapest best car ever

Faults:

It is like new, however, it stalled on me once on a round about for no unknown reason. The car has been professional checked and is fine. But nothing major has gone wrong with this car. I am very happy with it. I have been able to rely on it for long distances.

General Comments:

This car is great, very cheap to run and perfect for me because I'm only a small female, however, the pedals are ridiculously close and everyone who drives it has to take off their shoes so they don't press the brake and accelerator at the same time.

Would you buy another car from this manufacturer? Yes

Review Date: 26th September, 2002

1998 Holden Barina City 1.4 petrol

Summary:

Worst car ever

Faults:

Where to start?

The car felt bad from the start, I should have known what was to come, as when trying to accelerate I found that my right foot hit either the inside of the wheel arch or the brake pedal. My left foot would also hit the steering column when depressing the clutch.

The gearshift was terrible, both notchy and rubbery. I have never felt anything like it.

The wheel arches were faded.

The air conditioning never worked properly.

The lights in the heater controls blew and the mechanic had to break the switches just to get to them.

The car overheated at lights. Turned out the radiator had become blocked because the coolant in the cars didn't mix well with Australian water and turned into a sludge of some kind. The radiator had to be removed and flushed out.

The car overheated again. This time blowing the head gasket. Again the radiator was blocked. Got a new radiator. When the mechanic re-fitted the head, the front pulley was not tightened up properly and came off while driving. The car died. Turns out the lower crank gear also came off and the belt for the camshaft came off too. The car was towed to the dealership. It turns out the engine now had bent valves in the head so it had to be removed again.

The rear wheels were partially dragging and wore out the rear shoes in 20,000km. Rear shoes and wheel cylinders were replaced. Shoes were not expensive, but the wheel cylinders were well over $100 each.

There's more, but I just can't remember. Perhaps I am trying to block out all the bad memories of this car.

General Comments:

This is the worst car EVER made bar none. Terrible to drive and a disaster waiting to happen.

Would you buy another car from this manufacturer? No

Review Date: 5th February, 2002

22nd Sep 2003, 23:22

We had our Barina towed 13 times in the first two years with overheating problems, gasket problems, seals etc. The last service cost us over $2,000.00 for the head machining and oil leak fixes. We still have problems, and in hindsight should have got rid of it ages ago. With the money we have spent, I figure it must be getting close to being fixed. Friends of ours also have a Barina and not a single problem. We are not impressed with the car or Holden's service, where all our service work was done until the end of the extended warranty.

Paul S.

8th Sep 2006, 08:00

I have owned a SB Barina (1998) since new. I was the first owner. It has never missed a beat (very smooth engine).

Totally reliable, solid little car (compare to others in the same class from the same build date, it's no contest in the Barinas favour).

So I'd suggest these Barinas with issues have been abused.

8 years later I am about to trade on a CDTi Astra.

In reply to 8th Sep 2006, 08:00

23rd Oct 2013, 06:48

I'm inclined to agree. I bought my latest 1998 1.4 SB Barina second hand, knowing it had a blown head gasket. Actually I'm the third owner.

When we pulled it down, the oil was so compacted in one of the back hoses that it was totally solid, which indicates one of the two prior owners probably never changed the oil. It also had a blown water pump, and looks like it was running with this leak for ages.

What I have discovered though, is that whenever I've taken a Holden to a Holden dealer for a service, they always find that the brake pads need to be changed and a swag of other things need to be done.

I have the sneaking suspicion that Holden dealers at least use the service process as their main means of income, which is why we did the head gasket ourselves, despite not having any prior mechanical experience. All you need is a good instruction book, and research the Internet videos on the topic.