1999 Subaru Forester 2.5

Summary:

Great car, poor reliability

Faults:

The ozone detector failed at 17000 miles causing "engine warning" light -- left me on the shoulder of highway in remote PA. Repaired under warranty.

Seal between the engine and transmission failed. First detected and patched at 19000. Failed and patched again at 29000, 33000, and 46000. Finally dismantled and replaced entirely under warranty.

Both rear wheel bearings failed at 48000 -- not covered by warranty.

General Comments:

Good in snow and ice.

Would you buy another car from this manufacturer? Don't Know

Review Date: 12th April, 2003

1999 Subaru Forester S 2.5

Summary:

Need more work on quality

Faults:

Continuous problem on the engine. Got 2 major services done to repair leaks, including oil and coolant leaks. Same leak at the same spot keep happening after 2 replacements of gaskets.

General Comments:

Good car with nice features and performance, but lousy reliability. May be just bad luck. But on NHTSA site there are a few similar compliants from other Forester owners as well.

Would you buy another car from this manufacturer? No

Review Date: 15th October, 2002

25th Nov 2002, 22:26

I have had my 1998 Forester since it had 55,000 miles and had to replace my crank seal at 68,000 miles.

At least I was able to change the timing belt while in they were in there. Will save me a visit in the near future when it would have broke unexpectedly. I highly recommend having it changed if you have the opportunity after you hit 60,000 miles.

1999 Subaru Forester

Summary:

Good car, poor wheel bearings

Faults:

Wheel bearing problem at 41500 miles. These were straight highway miles (no off-road) In a facility of 200 workers I'm the third with wheel bearing problems in a Forester. All have occurred between 40,000 and 50,000 miles. By calling different Subaru dealers in my region of the country and speaking to the Parts Department (people who are a little more free with their information), I have found that many will not put Forester wheel bearings back on a Forester----they install Legacy bearings.

General Comments:

This is a Subaru problem and should not be passed down to the customer. There appears to be one of three scenarios. 1. Subaru is being supplied with bad or poorly designed parts. 2. Subaru has a design problem (using undersized bearings etc.). 3. Subaru has an installation problem. I think probably scenario no. 1 is the culprit. In any event this should be completely handled by Subaru with no cost to the customer. Wheel bearings do not wear out at 40,000 miles.

Would you buy another car from this manufacturer? Don't Know

Review Date: 19th June, 2002

21st Oct 2002, 19:18

I've just had a similar problem with my 1999 Subaru Forester, which has served me very well otherwise. The right rear wheel bearing has gone at 51,000 miles. Similar to other owners in the my situation, Subaru-USA says this problem is not covered by the 60,000 mile warranty, but nevertheless offered to cover the cost of the parts and I have to pay for labor costs. Judging from the various posts I've seen on different sites, this does indeed seem to be a manufacturing fault so I am also not sure why I should be paying anything.

1999 Subaru Forester S 2.5

Summary:

Trusty little beast

Faults:

Needed new rear rotors and pads at 36k miles.

General Comments:

I can't really say enough good stuff about this car. I can't blame the brakes on Subaru, it may have been the previous owners fault. Rotors were pitted and rusty when I got the car in Sept 2001. Subaru refused to cover them, even though I was still under the factory 3yr 36k warranty. Regardless, the car is FLAWLESS in the snow and a joy to drive fast on the highway! Standard features are options for other cars. Can't beat it. I commute 100 miles a day, and it's not let me down yet.

Would you buy another car from this manufacturer? Yes

Review Date: 2nd April, 2002

1999 Subaru Forester S 2.5 Liter

Summary:

I love my car

Faults:

Nothing.

General Comments:

I use this car to commute 65 miles one-way, from 3,000 feet and into town 4x week. It has incredible traction in my 4 months of snow and ice. Super responsive and reliable.

Would you buy another car from this manufacturer? Don't Know

Review Date: 7th April, 2001