1998 Peugeot 306 GLX 1.8 16v petrol

Summary:

Great car, but fragile and unreliable

Faults:

Stereo died twice.

Terrible radio reception.

Remote stalk stopped working.

Clutch failed.

Central locking plipper key disintegrated.

Engine blew up suddenly on the motorway at 45,000 resulting in a UKP3000 bill!

2 oil leaks.

Gearbox horrible when cold.

Battery kept going flat intermittently.

Heater control illumination failed.

General Comments:

This is a lovely car to drive. It handles like a hot hatch and the 1.8 litre engine is lively and very sweet. It also has great steering with loads of weight and feel.

However, it's all let down by shocking reliability. Most of it has been trivial things (everything to do with the stereo for instance), and a few duff bulbs.

More worrying though was a major mechanical failure at 45,000 miles. I was driving along the motorway with 3,000 RPM on the clock when suddenly it coughed and seized solid. Temp gauge was reading normally (80 degrees C) and all levels had been checked the same day. Turns out the head gasket had let go and dumped all the water out, but the gauge hadn't picked up the temperature increase.

The head was banana shaped and the bottom end had been shock loaded when it went from 3k to zero in a nanosecond. A complete new top end was fitted to a rebuilt bottom end for a dealership bill just shy of £3,000!! It runs okay now, although now leaks oil from the cam cover, and has been "fixed" twice. And it still leaks.

The clutch also gave up a week later after groaning and moaning for a few days. This also left me stranded. The new clutch hasn't improved the gearbox either which is horribly recalcitrant first thing in the morning.

The stereo is a joke. It sounds great, but if you catch it working, you're doing well. It won't pick up Capital FM cleanly on the M25 (!) and the code system went wrong, locking out the unit completely when the correct code was entered. This still hasn't been fixed! Also the column stalk controlling the volume and stations lost its functions one by one, until it died completely. This has been fixed apparently, but until the stereo itself works, I can't test it! Oh and when the plipper key button fell out, it was £85 + VAT for a replacement!

Somewhere in here is a great car. However, there can be no excuse for such shoddy engineering and build quality. Dynamically, the 306 wipes the floor with the competition, but I drive it just waiting for something else to go wrong. I also dread the £70 an hour bill from the dealer to put things right.

Much as I like the car itself, I couldn't honestly recommend it.

Would you buy another car from this manufacturer? Don't Know

Review Date: 11th January, 2002

28th Jun 2002, 14:14

I wrote the above review and can now add the following faults in just 3 months:

Engine kept cutting out when idling - dealer couldn't find fault and kept returning the car. By chance spoke to a friend with a similar car who had the same problem. When we told the dealer what it was, they eventually fixed it.

Airbag warning light now blinks continually.

Stalling problem has returned suddenly and now worse than ever.

Tappets are getting noisy.

Gearbox has developed an irritating whine between 3,000 and 4,000 RPM (right in the motorway cruising zone)

Offside front indicator intermittently refuses to work.

A total dog of a car - my patience has now run out!

11th Apr 2004, 09:53

I can honestly say that the 1.8 GLX ('98 on) is probably one of the best, but yet most annoying cars I have ever owned! The performance, handling, layout and features are probably the best in it's class - with poor reliability. If you know a good garage or mechanic, the parts are relatively inexpensive and an absolute doddle to fit - compared with the 306's competitors. A truly excellent car to mod as well - many modifications available (again, at reasonable cost), without the expense of buying the GTi-6. I owned the GLX from 1999 - 2003, putting around 50,000 miles on the clock - in total spending about £2,000 (admittedly most when it had it's 1st MOT) to maintain the car (this includes all parts/labour, tyres, etc etc) - which I would consider a reasonable spend for a four year period. The choice is yours, but be aware what can go wrong, and remember the golden rule: shop around and bargain for best prices!

1998 Peugeot 306 GLX 1.8 16v

Summary:

More fun than an Astra or Golf, and prettier too!

Faults:

Clutch noisy and excessively sharp - needs replacement at 42,000 miles. Most of the last keeper's mileage was in central London though.

Steering column control stalk for the (excellent) stereo is a bit temperamental since the car was serviced.

General Comments:

Although it will be better when the few niggling problems are sorted, the 306 is a great car to drive. It also still looks good too - vastly prettier in my opinion than its replacement, the van-like 307.

The 1.8 litre 16 valve engine is sweet, responsive, and delivers warm-hatch like performance. Thanks to the engine's refinement and a fairly tall fifth gear, the car is also capable of relaxed motorway cruising, being quiet and smooth at any remotely legal motorway speed. Fuel consumption is also good, averaging 30 mpg around town, and nudging 40 mpg on a run.

Steering is typically Peugeot - fast, full of feel and with just the right level of assistance. It gives you confidence when pressing on, and allows you to place the car millimetre perfect on the road.

The best thing about this car however, is the chassis. In GLX trim, the car is obviously set up for a comfortable ride rather than ultimate handling ability, but even so the balance of the car at the limit is deeply impressive and in a completely different league to most comparably priced cars.

Just like the XSi and GTI-6 models, you can induce lift off oversteer to help the car turn in, and the pointy steering and sheer balance of the car shame a lot of so called sports cars. The downside is that the car will bite you in the form of a spin if you're careless with it, but to be fair, you need to be pushing quite hard for this to become an issue. In any case I think it is much safer than the wash-out understeer you get in something like a Vauxhall Astra.

The GLX trim level comes well specced, with four electric windows, power steering, a basic, but effective climate control system, rain sensing wipers (good in theory but thoroughly irritating in practice!) and an excellent radio cassette with 6 disc CD changer and a stalk remote control. There are also a pair of nicely trimmed seats, which have a good range of adjustment - I'm 6'2", and my wife is 5'3" and we can both find a comfortable driving position.

The single worst aspect of the interior is the awful fake plastic wood which adorns the dash. I know this was dropped in later models for a much nicer silver effect, but buyers of this vintage of 306 beware! Overall though, the interior is pleasant enough, and the oft-heard gripes about 306 build quality seem to be unfounded. At 42,000 miles, and despite obvious neglect from its previous keeper, the interior cleans up almost as new, nothing squeaks or rattles, and everything except the stereo stalk works properly.

In my opinion, this is a good looking, quick-ish, well equipped, hatchback which offers a good dose of fun to boot. The dealers can be a bit hopeless at times, and the car is obsolete, but I can't think of a car in this class which looks as good, handles as well and is as much fun to drive. Especially impressive when most of the competition is a lot newer!

Would you buy another car from this manufacturer? Yes

Review Date: 25th July, 2001