2003 Renault Megane Authentique 1.5DCi from UK and Ireland
Summary:
German quality at French prices
Faults:
Electrical connection between clutch and starter button came adrift. Easily fixed by AA, and not a major issue.
General Comments:
When I purchased this car, I compared it to every other car in this segment, including the Golf, Civic, Focus, and Corolla, and felt that the Megane offered the best combination of looks, value, economy, comfort, performance, and build quality.
Quality is extremely high with superb materials used for the interior and excellent panel fit all round the car.
The dashboard is ergonomically designed, and the standard remote control for the stereo is excellent. When I purchased the car I got the dealer to fit a 6-CD changer in the boot, and the remote controls this as well.
I have never had a diesel before, but have been amazed at how quiet and refined the DCi technology is. This 1.5 is also extremely economical (returning an average of 65mpg on my daily commute) without sacrificing performances which benefits from class leading torque.
The innovative Renault Card system works well and the associated software supports in-car security extremely well. The Renault Anti-Intruder Device, which locks the doors automatically when the car moves is a welcome protection and a feature often available only on more expensive cars.
Renaults major on comfort (I also have a 2001 Clio Dynamique), and although I do 500 miles a week in the Megane I never feel cramped, uncomfortable or bored. I love every minute behind the wheel of this car and am convinced it is by far the best in its class. An excellent purchase.
Would you buy another car from this manufacturer? Yes
Review Date: 20th April, 2004
4th May 2004, 17:06
I have had 2 Megane saloons. The first one was alright, but clearly had some faults probably with the electronics as the Remote did not work properly all the time I owned it. And early last year it developed serious faults with the automatic gearbox at just 30,000kms. What is worrying is that the Dealer tested this car with Renault's CLIP diagnostic computer, and confirmed it was perfectly OK. A few miles later the car developed serious problems - terminal warning lamps on repeatedly, locking itself into 3rd gear and smoke from the engine bay. The dealer again insisted there was nothing wrong with it, so I traded it in for another one with 12,000km on the clock.
One year later and I have the same warning lamps for the auto gearbox, and once again Renault insist there is nothign wrong with it.
I just escaped a £3000+ bill for a new gearbox last time, and I am fighting hard to get the gearbox replaced this time. BUT Renault are awful to deal with. The car has now been in the garage for two weeks. They will not answer email and seemingly will not honour their warranty.
I am afraid this is the last Renault I shall ever buy. The cars are still typically French - not very well built, and nowhere near as reliable as e.g. my BMW.
Be warned.